So, the Minnesota state government shutdown is over. Let’s analyze the situation as it now stands, shall we?

The last three weeks were not all hugs and joy. (Photo: MPR)
Who won:
- Republicans. This budget was a GOP budget with no tax increases and significant spending cuts. GOP legislators get to keep their campaign promise of “no new taxes.”
- The very wealthy. No tax increases on top 2% of Minnesotans means that millionaires will get to keep more of their money. Sigh.
Who lost:
- Public education. Deferred payment to K-12 schools and large cuts to the University of Minnesota and MNSCU means that public education was the biggest loser in this budget. The Deferred payments to K-12 schools is just a way for the state to take out a loan from schools–very bad public policy.
- Governor Dayton. He has irritated fellow Democrats (they didn’t vote for this budget) and liberals who thought he should have stood up to the Republicans. Instead, he showed Republicans that if they wait him out long enough, he will cave under the pressure.
- Democrats. Their own Governor didn’t support them in the end. They appeared powerless to do anything during this whole debacle.
- Minnesota. All the national publicity about the government shutdown was not good for the state’s image. It can no longer be claimed that “Minnesota has a government that works.” Oh yes, and the state had its credit rating downgraded due in large part to the shutdown.
- State employees. Yes, now they are going back to work, and they didn’t get the full brunt of the ax that the Republicans wanted to bring down on them, it looks like they aren’t going to get back-pay during the state shutdown–in fact it seemed like Governor Dayton was rather ambivalent about the issue of back-pay. Still, a case can be made that it wasn’t state employees who caused the shutdown, so why should they be punished?
- The citizens of Minnesota. We have endured all this drama and angst–and what for? To have our state parks closed down during the busy tourism season? To have our roads not getting fixed? The list goes on and on…
- The children of Minnesota. Deferred payments to K-12 schools mean that schools are going to have to make tough choices about how to make ends meet. This will probably mean increased class sizes, fewer electives, and fewer extracurricular activities.
So, there you have it Minnesota. Admittedly, it is not a complete list, but you get the idea. I just hope we can deal with these nagging budget problems (through tax increases) sooner rather than later.